top of page

Your next party's conversation piece

Are you tired of boring cookies on your event’s dessert table? Looking for something fun and unique for your kid’s birthday party favours? We've got you covered with custom, soft-bite, and even interactive (Paint Your Own) sugar cookies. Let us help you create a standout party!

What We're Known For

Paint Your Own Cookies in Three Easy Steps

Imagine these interactive Paint Your Own (PYO) Cookies at your kid's next birthday party! Custom party favours that are great for all ages (we recommend always ordering an extra for yourself).





the proof is in the cookie

image_123650291 (1).JPG

Alicia is absolutely wonderful to work with, quick responses, amazing ideas and extremely friendly. Love, love love working with her and can't wait for the next birthday or holiday to order more!!! Highly recommend!!!

– Brittney .K

Even More Possibilities

Sweeten Your EVENT WITH Custom CookieS

Start your Custom Cookie journey by sharing your ideas and inspiration with us! Whether it's a special occasion or just a craving for personalized treats, we'll turn your visions into beautiful, delicious cookies.


Order & Consultation

Share your theme and vision with us. We're happy to brainstorm this with you!


Plan & Design

Alicia plans and sketches unique designs that will pair perfectly with your event.


Eat & Enjoy

Review the designs and then baking begins. Enjoy your delicious, edible art!

Owner of Crafty Cookiers, Alicia Buetter

About us

Hey cookie fan, thanks for checking out Crafty Cookiers! I'm Alicia, the creator, owner, and cookier behind the business. Our mission is to provide you with unique, buzz-worthy cookies that people won’t stop raving about, for all of your events! Whether you’re looking for corporate logo cookies, interactive cookies for your child’s birthday party, extravagant wedding cookies, or a private cookie decorating class for girls night, we’ve got you covered!!


We create custom cookies that taste the BEST and help you create a standout party. No matter how abstract your vision, we’ll bring it to life in edible art form. Go ahead, take a bite out of creativity and join us on this tasty adventure. After all, life’s too short for boring cookies.


Browse our Cookie Shop, check out our Instagram page to see our work, and reach out to us with any questions you have; we’d love to chat through them with you.



Follow Crafty Cookiers on social for inspiration & updates:

bottom of page